moneycalc

Rent vs Buy Calculator

Compare the true cost of renting versus buying a home over time. Accounts for mortgage payments, property taxes, maintenance, home appreciation, and investment opportunity cost.

Home Purchase

$
%
%
%

Annual rate as % of home value

$/yr
%

Annual maintenance as % of home value

%
%

Agent fees and closing costs when you sell, as % of the sale price

Renting

$
%
%

Expected annual return if you invest the down payment and monthly savings instead

years

How long you plan to stay

Verdict

Renting saves more
by $8,007 over 7 years
Buying
Monthly Payment (P&I)$1,770
Property Tax$350
Insurance$125
Maintenance$292
Total Monthly Cost$2,536
Home Value (future)$430,456
Equity After Selling Costs$151,463
Net Cost of Buying$136,700
Renting
Starting Rent$2,000
Total Rent Paid$183,899
Investment Balance$159,470
Net Cost of Renting$128,693

How the Rent vs. Buy Calculation Works

This calculator compares the net financial cost of renting versus buying over your chosen time horizon. For buying, it totals mortgage payments (principal and interest), property taxes, insurance, and maintenance — then subtracts the equity you build (home value minus remaining loan balance). For renting, it totals rent payments with annual increases, then credits the growth of investments you could make with the down payment and any monthly savings from lower rent.

The comparison hinges on opportunity cost: money used for a down payment cannot be invested elsewhere. If stock market returns exceed home appreciation, the renter's invested capital may outpace the homeowner's equity. Conversely, leverage (borrowing 80% of the home value) amplifies the homeowner's return on their actual cash invested.

Key Factors That Tilt the Decision

Time horizon is the most important factor. Transaction costs (closing costs, agent fees) typically run 5-8% of the home price, creating a high bar for short stays. Local rent-to-price ratio matters: in cities where monthly rent is less than 0.5% of the purchase price, renting is often cheaper. Mortgage rates at 7%+ dramatically increase the cost of buying compared to 3-4% rates. And maintenance costs — averaging 1-2% of home value annually — are the hidden expense most first-time buyers underestimate.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long do I need to stay for buying to make sense?

The breakeven point is typically 5-7 years for most markets. Buying involves large upfront costs (closing costs, down payment opportunity cost) that take time to recoup through equity growth. If you plan to move within 3 years, renting usually wins once closing costs and agent commissions are counted, which this calculator does not model. Beyond 7 years, buying tends to win in most scenarios due to fixed mortgage payments vs. rising rents.

What investment return should I assume for the renting scenario?

A balanced portfolio (60/40 stocks/bonds) has historically returned 7-8% annualized before inflation. If you are conservative, use 5-6%. The key insight is that renters can invest their down payment in the stock market instead of tying it up in a house, and stocks have historically outperformed real estate on a total-return basis.

Does this calculator account for tax benefits of homeownership?

This version focuses on the core financial comparison. In practice, homeowners may deduct mortgage interest and property taxes if they itemize (about 10% of filers post-2017 tax reform). For most buyers, the standard deduction exceeds these itemized amounts, so the tax benefit is smaller than commonly believed.

How does home appreciation affect the calculation?

Home appreciation is the biggest variable. The US national average is about 3-4% annually, but local markets vary widely. High-appreciation markets (Austin, Nashville) tilt the math toward buying, while stagnant markets favor renting. Be cautious with assumptions above 5% — sustained double-digit appreciation is historically rare.

Related Calculators